EVERYTHING ON SALE - WAVE 2B PREORDER COMING SOON!

An Honest Chat About Shipping

Hey everyone.


Since our last update, we’ve seen a lot of disappointed messages about shipping fees for the last wave of items. Most of these have a common theme, bringing up past promises we’ve made over this several-year campaign. We’re writing this to be real with you; you’re right to be disappointed.


We’d like to share what’s going on and how we got here.



First, Not Everyone Will Need To Pay Again

 

We will not be charging shipping to any customer who placed an order on our last preorder, paid shipping and has not received anything yet.



This accounts for roughly 10% of you.



Once we open up the BackerKit pledge managers again, you’ll know if you’re in this group because you’ll have no balance. You already paid the market rate for shipping and you’re good to go.



What About The Other 90%?


The remaining 90% is anyone who paid for shipping and already got items in the last wave. The shipping fees we collected were already used to pay the costs of shipping those items. We hoped we could cover the cost of shipping the rest of your order.


 Unfortunately, our delays in development and current market conditions have simply made that impossible.


What Happened?


We thought we could cover the shipping of both waves using the payment we collected on our last wave. We also outright said in a few official updates that those who paid shipping on the last wave would not be required to pay for the final wave of items.


We had good reason to believe we could achieve this at the time, but our plans didn’t end up working out the way we hoped.


This was a combination of personal mistakes, significant underestimation of remaining development time, optimism about shipping prices, external miscommunication, and serious gaps in our accounting of shipping costs.


We made this campaign way too complex. That left us blind to the realities in the scope of the problem in front of us, and ultimately caused significant delays in our development time. That’s really what got us here; by the time the game was fully playtested and we’d completed QC, the market had moved on right past us. The costs we once had enough cash to cover have now swallowed that reserve completely, bringing us to this position.


It was reckless and unfair to promise that the 2023 payment would cover all remaining shipping when we weren’t even sure when design would be completed. It shouldn’t be your problem. If we were some huge megacorporation, we could pull money from some other department to cover shipping and eat it on this. But we’re not, we’re a few friends making a game we love. The cash just isn’t there.


Your Criticism Is Warranted


Since our first Kickstarter in 2015, we’ve been trying to get this overly ambitious campaign delivered while shouldering as much of the burden of shipping as possible. On that campaign, we honored our promise of free shipping, which was only possible thanks to some outside funding sources.


But the reality now is that as fuel prices, tariffs, import duties, fulfillment fees, and ocean freight costs have all risen dramatically, we’ve failed to offset the cost elsewhere. We wanted to make it happen, but we simply can’t afford to get this wave shipped without your help.


Again, it was completely unfair and recklessly optimistic for us to make such an ambitious promise to you and for that we’re sorry.


The Logistics


We’re still learning how to optimize shipping for a game like Middara.



We've historically gotten ourselves into trouble shipping this game. We know how lame it feels to get a giant bill for a crowdfunded shipping cost, because we’re backers in campaigns like these too.


We hate paying for shipping both as a customer and as a company.


The truth is that the cost of shipping this campaign has exceeded $1.5M, and that’s without the cost of the final wave.



All the capital available to us at the moment is earmarked for the production of this gigantic wave. The scope of Act 2 + 3 is huge, and getting the game we’ve been wanting to share with all of you actually in print and plastic will take all we’ve got left.



There’s just no way around it, we need your help to get this fulfilled. That’s why we’re asking for these shipping payments.


What Will Change In The Future?


Under Promise, Over Deliver:


This means ensuring that we are not making promises we cannot keep. Our past optimism continues to haunt us, and we are learning to be more honest with ourselves so that we can be honest with you. It means charging what things actually cost, not the deal we hope to score to bring it down.


Smaller Scale Projects:


This is the only way. Projects we do in the future will be the size of our first wave and no bigger. Something that fits in a single shipment. We can still tell awesome stories and make big games. But we need to get it all out the door at once, so we’re less vulnerable to market forces. It means future campaigns being in playtesting before they even launch for crowdfunding.


Shipping in a Single Wave:


This goes without saying, but breaking up a campaign into 4 or 5 waves of shipping over the course of years is just not the way to do it and is a direct consequence of the complexity of the campaign. We cannot and will not do this again.


Sign Off


As we near closing this Kickstarter out, we again want to apologize for our fumbles and follies throughout this campaign. We know how to make great games, but haven’t been great at getting them to you efficiently.

This campaign has been enormously stressful, overwhelming, and could have been managed better from the start. We promised too much and kicked the accountability down the road, hoping to pull off a miracle that never came.

You all have given us an opportunity to make a living designing games. We understand that in many aspects, we’ve let you down.

Right now, our primary goal is to make sure we get you the products that we promised you we would.

Thanks for checking our update and we'll talk to you soon.